Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

·2026 ·1 Season ·Mystery

After her breakup, Cheryl inherits an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek, hoping for a fresh start. But eerie stuffed animals, a sudden kidnapping, and buried town rivalries quickly shatter the calm. Forced to team up with Naomi and Levi, Cheryl plunges into a dangerous hunt through hidden secrets and old grudges, racing to uncover the truth before it’s too late.

Play Similars

Seasons & Episodes

Season 1 Season 1 8 ep
1
The Buggy Before the Horse
The Buggy Before the Horse
2026-04-23
2
A Season of Secrets
A Season of Secrets
2026-04-30
3
O Little Town of Sugarcreek
O Little Town of Sugarcreek
2026-05-07
4
Off the Beaten Path
Off the Beaten Path
2026-05-14
5
Simply Vanished
Simply Vanished
2026-05-21
6
Stitch in Time
Stitch in Time
2026-05-28
7
Mason Jar Mayhem
Mason Jar Mayhem
2026-06-04
8
When There’s a Will
When There’s a Will
2026-06-11

Actors

Galadriel Stineman
Galadriel Stineman
Acting
Denise Gossett
Denise Gossett
Acting
Kevin Joy
Kevin Joy
Acting
Lance E. Nichols
Lance E. Nichols
Acting
Ryan O'Quinn
Ryan O'Quinn
Acting
Riley Beeson
Riley Beeson
Acting

You may like

Pritam and Pedro
Pritam and Pedro
2026 TV
Murder in the Skies: Who Downed Mh17?
Murder in the Skies: Who Downed Mh17?
8.0 2025 TV
Oasis
Oasis
6.8 2026 TV
Notes from the Last Row
Notes from the Last Row
9.2 2026 TV
TAGUSARI bros.
TAGUSARI bros.
6.3 2026 TV
The Killings at Parrish Station
The Killings at Parrish Station
5.7 2026 TV
The Trouble With Tessa
The Trouble With Tessa
1.0 2025 TV
Theatre Macabre
Theatre Macabre
3.0 1971 TV